Review: SmoothDraw vs Artweaver

You may have noticed a little upsurge in “hand-drawn” comics in the past couple of weeks, the most prominent being Grampa Scientist.

I’ve been using the Wacom Pen tablet I got a few weeks ago and I’ve been experimenting with various drawing software. The one I prefer – so far – is SmoothDraw. I like its simplicity, which is important, given that I draw simple cartoons.

This past week, I tried Artweaver. It’s surprisingly rich for a freeware, runs smoothly and has an interface like Photoshop. The problem was its actual complexity. For all its great features, it took me ages to find a simple felt pen for sketching. There are just so many settings and adjustments etc for every one of the available “brushes” that it just became counterproductive. And even when I managed to find a setting that allowed me to sketch, it didn’t have the liquidity that SmoothDraw provides. Also, drawing often suffered from lag, especially with quick strokes or long continuous lines.

Colouring in was also a pain, as you have to change the pixelation (“threshold”) of your sketch to avoid horrible white marks. SmoothDraw on the other hand is a bit more intuitive and fills things out a lot nicer.

Overall, it seems that Artweaver is better for deep, artistic work. When it comes to line art and colouring, I’d recommend SmoothDraw (which actually has more features than the average cartoonist will ever need!). Anyway, they’re both free, so give them a try and find the one that works for you.

Still, I did draw something with Artweaver. Here you go:

Tablet drawing!

My Wacom Bamboo Pen tablet came in today. It’s great, but it’ll take some time to co-ordinate moving my hand while watching the screen.

Here’s an early attempt.

It’s part of a comic lablit “noir” series that I’m hoping to draw when I’m more fluent with the pen.

Stay tuned, and feedback/advice is always welcome!

More mouse drawing

Weekends aren’t the best for blogging. The whole of the Web seems to quiet down like a de-sugarised child, and with the sun shining even here in the UK, it’s great to know that we can still escape the allure of the screen and go out to photosynthesise.

So today I’m posting just another attempt of drawing with my mouse. Still trying to figure out what PC drawing tablet to go for (on a reasonable budget), so any suggestions are welcome.

I have no idea what this image means. It just happened. I blame my mouse.

What do you make of it?